Tales of Middle-earth Commander card values

Market reference estimates for the 561 priced cards in the 2023 Tales of Middle-earth Commander, built from what ungraded copies have recently sold for, as of 2026-09-29.

Full set · one of each · ungraded

$34,016

THE 12 BELOW ARE $28,066 OF IT

Showing 1–12 of 561 · top 12 by value
Rank	Card	Market
01	Cavern of Souls#392z	$10,000
02	Shinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep#404z	$3,300
03	Sword of Hearth and Home#384z	$3,000
04	Sol Ring#409z	$2,750
05	Karakas#397z	$2,700
06	Castle Ardenvale#391z	$2,200
07	Sol Ring#408	$1,658
08	Pillar of the Paruns#402z	$750
09	Sol Ring#409	$558
10	Sol Ring#410	$463
11	Ancient Tomb#387	$387
12	Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth#405	$301

Half the set is under $1.43 a card

The value lives at the top, which is normal for Magic: The Gathering — famous is not the same as dear.

Top of the set1 of 561

Cavern of Souls

#392z · MTG

$10,000

The real card

Linked from Scryfall for this exact printing — Grailry stores no card art. Scan your own copy and your vault shows your photograph of it.

Get Grailry — free

50 free scans to start, then 5 a month

More Magic: The Gathering sets

Limited Edition Alpha$224,921 Limited Edition Beta$130,579 Secret Lair Drop$54,836 Unlimited Edition$54,005 30th Anniversary Edition$38,989 Ravnica Remastered$32,356 The Hobbit$27,602 Seventh Edition$24,330 Multiverse Legends$22,853 The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth$22,567 Final Fantasy$22,473 The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts$17,844

Values are market reference estimates, not appraisals or financial advice: what ungraded copies have recently sold for, not what sellers are asking, so they can sit well below a set's listed prices. A dated snapshot of the catalogue, taken on 2026-09-29. Condition changes everything; a graded copy is a different card. Card images are linked from Scryfall and are © Wizards of the Coast; Grailry is not affiliated with them. Every set we price →