Grailry logoGRAILRY

Judge Gift Cards 2023 card values

Market reference estimates for the 10 priced cards in the 2023 Judge Gift Cards 2023, built from what ungraded copies have recently sold for, as of 2026-09-29.

Full set · one of each · ungraded
$247
THE 10 BELOW ARE $247 OF IT
Showing 1–10 of 10 · top 10 by value
RankCardMarket
01
Painter's Servant card
Painter's Servant#1
$71.33
02
Mycosynth Lattice card
Mycosynth Lattice#3
$43.04
03
Forest card
Forest#10
$26.07
04
Island card
Island#7
$24.19
05
Grindstone card
Grindstone#2
$21.69
06
Retrofitter Foundry card
Retrofitter Foundry#4
$15.05
07
Plains card
Plains#6
$12.71
08
Sword of War and Peace card
Sword of War and Peace#5
$12.19
09
Swamp card
Swamp#8
$12
10
Mountain card
Mountain#9
$8.65
Half the set is under $18.37 a card

The value lives at the top, which is normal for Magic: The Gathering — famous is not the same as dear.

Top of the set1 of 10
Painter's Servant
#1 · MTG
$71.33
The real card

Linked from Scryfall for this exact printing — Grailry stores no card art. Scan your own copy and your vault shows your photograph of it.

Painter's Servant card
Get Grailry — free
50 free scans to start, then 5 a month

More Magic: The Gathering sets

Planar Chaos$252Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019$252Betrayers of Kamigawa$251Crimson Vow Commander$249Coldsnap$248Guilds of Ravnica Promos$248Secrets of Strixhaven Promos$246Midnight Hunt Commander$245Commander 2018$245Dissension$237Unglued$234Time Spiral Timeshifted$232

Values are market reference estimates, not appraisals or financial advice: what ungraded copies have recently sold for, not what sellers are asking, so they can sit well below a set's listed prices. A dated snapshot of the catalogue, taken on 2026-09-29. Condition changes everything; a graded copy is a different card. Card images are linked from Scryfall and are © Wizards of the Coast; Grailry is not affiliated with them. Every set we price →