Judge Gift Cards 2012 card values

Market reference estimates for the 9 priced cards in the 2012 Judge Gift Cards 2012, built from what ungraded copies have recently sold for, as of 2026-09-29.

Full set · one of each · ungraded

$432

THE 9 BELOW ARE $432 OF IT

Showing 1–9 of 9 · top 9 by value
Rank	Card	Market
01	Xiahou Dun, the One-Eyed#1	$93.71
02	Noble Hierarch#3	$86.86
03	Flusterstorm#2	$81.18
04	Command Tower#8	$49.72
05	Sneak Attack#5	$45.84
06	Karakas#6	$30.26
07	Sword of Light and Shadow#7	$28.81
08	Karmic Guide#4	$14.72
09	Centaur#9	$1.17

Half the set is under $45.84 a card

The value lives at the top, which is normal for Magic: The Gathering — famous is not the same as dear.

Top of the set1 of 9

Xiahou Dun, the One-Eyed

#1 · MTG

$93.71

The real card

Linked from Scryfall for this exact printing — Grailry stores no card art. Scan your own copy and your vault shows your photograph of it.

Get Grailry — free

50 free scans to start, then 5 a month

More Magic: The Gathering sets

Eldritch Moon Promos$454 Reality Fracture$454 Marvel's Spider-Man Promos$448 Fifth Dawn$445 Dominaria United Commander$434 Hour of Devastation Promos$432 Shadows over Innistrad Promos$430 Judge Gift Cards 2017$429 Amonkhet Promos$428 Masters 25$420 Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander$419 From the Vault: Realms$417

Values are market reference estimates, not appraisals or financial advice: what ungraded copies have recently sold for, not what sellers are asking, so they can sit well below a set's listed prices. A dated snapshot of the catalogue, taken on 2026-09-29. Condition changes everything; a graded copy is a different card. Card images are linked from Scryfall and are © Wizards of the Coast; Grailry is not affiliated with them. Every set we price →